Second Rate Democracy

Seventeen Ways America is Less Democratic than other Major Western Countries and How We Can Do Better

A web project of Douglas J. Amy, Professor Emeritus of Politics, Mount Holyoke College

Seventeen Ways America is Less Democratic than other Major Western Countries and How We Can Do Better

A web project of Douglas J. Amy, Professor Emeritus of Politics, Mount Holyoke College

Today, when most people worry about the state of U.S. democracy, they focus on the threats to democracy posed by President Trump – his contempt for the rule of law, the Constitution, fair elections, etc. But that’s not what this web project is about. It’s about the deep structural problems that have always plagued our democracy and how other major Western countries enjoy much better democratic systems. For a long time, the U.S. has been afflicted by a malfunctioning political system. Key political institutions (the Electoral College, the Senate, our voting system, the Supreme Court, and the Constitution itself) have consistently violated basic democratic norms like fair representation, majority rule, and political equality. These serious problems will persist long after Trump is gone and they need to be addressed. Read the Introduction


What is this site about?

Frustrated with American politics? You should be. This site explains why American democracy is failing, which special interests benefit from this, what we can learn from other countries, and what reforms need to be adopted.

Learn more about this project

What Can You Do?

Learn what you can do.  Here is a list of some of the major reform groups that you can join and/or support in their efforts to bring real democracy to our country.

See the resource list

Want to Learn More?

To gain a deeper understanding, here is a list of books that provide a more comprehensive and well-documented analysis of these issues and explore in more detail some possible solutions.

See the book list

[ back to top ]